Hello dear
Welcome To Wally’s Old Fashioned Pizza
At Wally’s Old Fashioned Pizza, tradition meets taste in Caldwell, OH. With a commitment to quality, Wally’s offers a delightful array of pizza and sub sandwiches crafted from fresh ingredients. Their original cheese prime pan pizza, featuring a delectable garlic butter crust, showcases the perfect balance of flavors, while their supreme option bursts with toppings. The inviting atmosphere, with outdoor seating and dog-friendly policies, makes it a family-friendly destination. Whether you're seeking a quick takeout or a gathering with friends, Wally’s is dedicated to delivering delicious food and a warm experience that brings everyone together.
About
Wally’s Old Fashioned Pizza
Welcome to Wally’s Old Fashioned Pizza, a cherished gem nestled in Caldwell, Ohio. Known for its authentic old-fashioned recipes and generous portions, Wally’s has quickly earned a reputation for serving some of the best pizza in the region. If you're a pizza aficionado or just someone seeking a hearty meal, this is the place to be.
At Wally's, every pie is crafted with care. Take, for instance, their Original Cheese Prime Pan Pizza. Each slice boasts a golden garlic butter crust, layered with sumptuous provolone cheese and premium pepperoni, all culminating in a delightful garlic herb blend. Or, for those who crave a bit of everything, the Supreme Prime Pan Pizza is a feast for the senses, featuring an array of toppings — from pepperoni and mushrooms to olives and bacon — that come together beautifully.
- Appetizers: Start your meal with their crispy traditional wings or boneless wings, baked to perfection and ready to be tossed in your choice of sauce, from BBQ to spicy ranch.
- Sub Sandwiches: Don’t miss out on their Italian Sub, bursting with sliced ham, pepperoni, and provolone, garnished with fresh veggies and Italian dressing.
The ambiance at Wally’s is family-friendly and welcoming. With outdoor seating available and a setup perfect for groups, it’s an ideal spot to gather with friends or family. Dogs are welcome too, making it a delightful choice for pet owners. For those on the go, Wally’s offers convenient takeout options, so you can enjoy their delicious food wherever you are.
Customer reviews echo the love for Wally’s. Sandra Norris passionately declares that their pizza is “the best anywhere,” while Steve McCull reminisces about the unbeatable crunchy crust and tangy sauce he enjoyed since childhood. These sentiments highlight not only the quality of the food but the warmth and nostalgia associated with each bite.
So, if you find yourself craving mouthwatering pizza and hearty subs, make your way to Wally’s Old Fashioned Pizza at 805 Miller St, Caldwell, OH 43724, or give them a call at (740) 732-4241. Indulge in a slice of nostalgia and discover why so many have fallen in love with Wally's delicious offerings.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Omg if you have not had Wallys Pizza you need to go get one. We live in Belpre Ohio and we come to get our fix on the Best Pizza anywhere. We Love Wallys Pizza. It just Awesome. it. ”
“ I have been eating Cambridge Caldwell Wallys pizza since child hood! Best in the region if notthe State. Crunchy crust, every piece, every time. Sauce has the tang , cheese is just gooy strings right! The Hawaiian had big chunchs of pineapple ! Hmmmm...so goooood! ”
“ Really good food, large portions for the price. Dry rub wings, subs, calzones, buffalo ranch pizza, and more... ”
“ I had the Italian sub and I hadnt had a good sub in years and to try it was worth the risk plus it was right before they closed and we all know how those last minute customers call and as the employee you dont want to answer so they ... ”
“ Theyve got all these crazy toppings to choose from, like pepperoni, sausage, and even pineapple if youre into that kind of thing. So, if youre ever craving some amazing pizza, you gotta hit up Pizza Place. Trust me, you wont regret it! ”
“ I went in today for the first time and the staff was so friendly and helpful. I needed to feed my coworkers and I had no idea what to get. I was exhausted and I wasnt able to think straight. Brad and the two girls working the front were so ... ”
“ At first glance the pizza doesnt look impressive but I have to say its most certainly delicious. Their crust game is on point! The staff was super accommodating and polite. ”
“ Meat lovers pizza was the best Ive had. ”